Once upon a time, Godfrey Lake was more than just an afterthought to the thousands of motorists who pass by it every day as they drive on Herbertsville Road.
But for many years, township officials have not known what, exactly, they could do to improve the lake's condition. The problem: nobody knows who owns it.
After the township started digging into records dating back to the 1920s several years ago, they came up with more questions than answers. Business Administrator Scott Pezarras said a title search revealed that the lake's owner is the estate of the president of the defunct corporation that developed the area around the lake.
That scenario presents an entirely new set of issues, according to Township Attorney Jean Cipriani, who said the township must find the owner's heirs in order to take any action on the property, including condemning the lake.
"No matter what, we have to find these heirs," Cipriani said.
For that search to take place, there could be a "significant cost," she added.
If no heirs can be found, there is a process by which the township could condemn the lake on its own, though Cipriani said "every reasonable attempt" must be made to locate the would-be lake owners before any condemnation proceedings could commence.
The last sign of its past still remains partially intact: seven pilings that once made up a dock, perhaps a platform from which swimmers could jump in the water on a warm summer day.
The lake was once part of a bungalow community known as the Godfrey Manor Country Club, after it was developed in the mid 1920s by Charles F. Godfrey and E.L. Godfrey, according to the book "Greetings From Brick Township," written by township historian Gene Donatiello.
At some point, the bungalow community organization was dissolved, leaving the lake's status up in the air.
For decades, the sizable lake has been largely forgotten despite its prime location alongside one of the township's most heavily-traveled roads.
From time to time, someone brings up the fact that something must be done about its appearance. A rusty guard rail on Herbertsville Road isn't aesthetically pleasing, people say, nor are the empty soda and beer cans that litter its shores. The water, most would agree, does not appear suitable for swimming.
For years, the lake was heavily overgrown with lilly pads and weeds. During most summers, the vegetation reappears.
The lake's owner may not want to step out of the shadows, however.
Cipriani said whomever owns the lake could be responsible for years of unpaid property taxes.