.
Feedback

Animal Cruelty Suspect Makes First Court Appearance

Nat Sladkin appears in Brick municipal court

One of the two operators of the Brick Township pet shop made an appearance in municipal court Thursday night.

Nathan "Nat" Sladkin, a 71-year-old Farmingdale resident who managed the Puppies Galore pet store on Hooper Avenue, appeared before Judge Robert Lepore for an arraignment hearing.

Sladkin is facing four counts of cruelty to animals filed by investigators with the New Jersey Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. The owner of the store, Old Bridge resident Maria De Santis, 57, is facing 38 counts of animal cruelty.

Dressed in a black jacket, khaki pants and a red shirt, Sladkin tilted his head to the side and quietly listened to Lepore read the potential penalties for each charge – up to six months in the county jail and a fine of $1,000, plus various court fees. He could also face between one and three years of probation.

After the charges were read, Sladkin briskly walked out of the court room, then refused to comment on the case to a reporter, saying, "no comment."

De Santis was also scheduled to appear in court Thursday, but her appearance was adjourned after she had retained an attorney, court staff told Brick Patch.

Sladkin told a court officer he was planning on hiring an attorney as he walked out of the .

The cruelty charges against Sladkin and De Santis arose after authorities removed 39 puppies from the store they operated. Of the 39, veterinarians identified 26 as being ill, including four who were severely ill and were taken to a veterinary trauma center.

Officials with the SPCA said earlier this week that the charges were filed for failure to provide necessary sustenance in the form of veterinary care for the puppies.

Sladkin's legal troubles date back decades. According to a 1995 article that appeared in the Philadelphia Inquirer, Sladkin and his wife were ordered to pay $17,500 in fines stemming from his operation of a pet store on Arnold Avenue in Point Pleasant Beach. That store, Pet Depot, is now closed.

A hearing on the status on the Brick store is set for Tuesday at 6:30 p.m., township officials confirmed this week.

The puppies that were removed from the store are being held at animal shelters while the case is being resolved.

. February 11, 2012 at 05:42 pm
How could the dogs have had all of their shots and not been to a vet for annual checkups? It is during an annual checkup that dogs receive their shots! I don't agree with what the shelters decide at times, but if your sister doesn't take proper care of the pets she has and then lies to another shelter to obtain another pet, maybe they were right this time.
Joe February 11, 2012 at 06:45 pm
you people should channel your energy towards Abortion Clinics! I love dogs, but where is the rage about babies being murdered everyday for the last 40 years.
Laura February 11, 2012 at 10:47 pm
wrong site for you, Joe
Try Evangelicals to go.
frances February 12, 2012 at 02:33 am
<>HAPPY VALENTINES DAY for those with a HEART <> 1/2 hour is all it will take <>
Folks please make an effort to show your support for these innocent animals. Join us at the hearing to be held on February 14th, 6:30 pm at 401 Chambers Bridge Rd, Brick NJ (Council Chambers A&B) and continue to contact your elected officials and remind them that we will do whatever it takes to end the abuse and mistreatment of animals. We can make a difference in protecting these defenseless animals from the likes of unethical, abusive store owners, brokers, and breeders.
Sean Conneamhe February 12, 2012 at 12:16 pm
"Also take a look at The Pet Asylum store on Herbertsville Road at 22nd Avenue."
brick mom 61 February 12, 2012 at 01:02 pm
Townships have rabies clinics, which are much cheaper than the vets, and just because you don't spend hundreds at a vet for things like Lyme disease testing does not mean your dogs are not cared for. In today's financial climate, you must pick and choose which bills you are going to pay. My annual vet bill for 1 dog is well over $300 for all the testing recommended by my vet. That is alot of money. My point is that instead of trying to put pets in good homes, they make it difficult for people who do love and care for their pets, while the pet stores will sell to anyone.
Ann February 13, 2012 at 11:43 pm
You sir...should check your facts before you say such ignorant words!!! My rage is directed at people like you, who makes such STUPID statements.
Bricktown Lew February 14, 2012 at 01:32 am
We have to shut all of these pet stores that sell puppies. Also, we have to educate people not only NOT to support these places, but learn responsible dog ownership. I read some comments about shelters rejecting certain individuals pet adoption offers. Well, find out why and do what is necessary to get the adoption though. Shelters aren't trying to hold animals back because they want to keep animals at the shelters. They just want to make sure that the animals in which they invested so much in with rescue go to proper homes for permanent adoption...not add to the problem.
Now, let's shut these puppy places down. Spread the word to keep family, friends, and neighbors away from those places!
BW February 14, 2012 at 02:52 am
Lew " I read some comments about shelters rejecting certain individuals pet adoption offers. Well, find out why and do what is necessary to get the adoption though"
A shelter or rescue will not allow you to adopt if you are a senior on social security, they say you "cannot afford to love a pet" If you have never had a pet before, sorry you are out of luck. If you dont supply years and years of vet records, you are a not a candidate to adopt. If you have small children, you can not adopt. I heard one person say they were turned down because they did the humane thing and put a suffering pet down, instead of paying thousands on medical treatment that probably wouldnt work any way. I am all for shutting down puppy stores and puppy mills. I am also all for shelters being more pro adoption and less judgemental and refuse to let people adopt because they are not as perfect as as the shelters workers think they are.
Bricktown Lew February 14, 2012 at 04:21 pm
@Me
All shelters have different adoption policies to avoid having adopted animals neglected or abused and returned often. Returning a recently adopted animal doesn't help the situation. Also, there are many things needed to be taken into consideration. People, especially in this hard economy think about adoption first, then affording the animal last. That's not good. Adopting a puppy when having a baby or young child can be asking for trouble because of the attention kids and puppies need in general. Also puppies are playful, energetic, and can accidentally hurt young kids. So some shelters will reject puppy adoptions. Some people without dominant breed experience may not be able to adopt one at certain shelters for safety reasons and so adopters don't "bite off more than they can chew" and return the animal. As for vet records or pet euthanasia, those things are taken into consideration. For example, I've heard about some people euthanizing their older pets simply because it was more of a financial issue than a medical issue. If one is a senior citizen and would have trouble to keep a pet in a normal, healthy way, they may be rejected. However, there are programs in our area for seniors in need of care to get volunteer visits with service dogs. So when it comes down to for shelters is "better safe than sorry" because they would be receiving the animal back if the adoption went sour. Also, what about issues stemming directly from pet store adoptions?
BW February 14, 2012 at 04:28 pm
Kind of hypocritical isnt it? They will deny you a pet if you did the humane thing and put down a pet who was suffering, and at the same time the shelters are putting down animals because they have been in the shelter too long and hasnt been adopted.
Lew have you gone to a shelter and filled out the 6 page application? Some of the questions are unreal. One said when you go on vacation will you take the animal with you or find a sitter, if you answered sitter, please give the name, address and phone number of the sitter. The list is endless. Shelters and rescues have gone over the top when it comes to adoption. In the state of NJ it is easier to adopt a child then it is to adopt a pet!
Bricktown Lew February 14, 2012 at 05:24 pm
Sometimes it can be ironic in certain circumstances. Like I said, euthanasia can be a touchy subject because some will put animals to sleep as a way of convenience than medical necessity. That can pose a problem for the next adoption. Now, some shelter policies will have a certain period of time they hold an animal before being euthanized. Other shelters, like Jersey Shore Animal Shelter, have no time limit. They hold any adoptable animal in hopes of adoption as long as it is adoptable. However, all shelters are not the same.
Being a former shelter volunteer and running a K-9 service, I have seen those applications. The vacation question is very important. Also, the questions like if the animal will be living indoors is also very important. Why? Well, because there are people out there that would leave for vacation and have a friend go to the house once every few days to give the poor dog some food and check the dirty water level in the bowl. There are also some that plan on keeping their pet outdoors all year long or simply as a "watchdog" or "mouse cat" in a barn. That is not responsible ownership. Some have even used adopted animals simply for breeding a litter and then returning the pet when they are done! Those are some reasons why there are so many questions on the applications. Let's not forget the question about if there are animals that are fixed or not. Why? Because anytime there is a risk of puppies or kittens, there is a risk of strays. I know, It's a shame.
BW February 14, 2012 at 07:51 pm
Lew let me tell you my experience with the shelter in Brick. I have done cat rescues for many years. I have one cat I got when she was only 3 weeks old. I bottle feed her for 4 weeks until she was able to eat regular cat food. She just turned 17 in Dec. I went to the Brick shelter looking at adopt another cat. I filled out the huge application, answered honestly, and gave them the phone number for my vet. I got a call the following day tell me I was unfit as a pet owner, and the should come to my home and rescue the cat I had. Want to know why I was unfit?? Because when the cat was 6 months old I had her spayed and front paws declawed!. Yup true story. My vet was like omg you wouldnt believe what these people asked me. They wanted him to fax over 16 years of vet records! They asked him if he KNEW declawing a cat was abuse. Unreal.
A lot of people I know who have tried to adopt and were turned down for really stupid reasons, either answer ads in the paper or go on Craigs list to find a pet. It is a real shame the shelters would rather destroy an animal then adopt them out.
Bricktown Lew February 14, 2012 at 10:15 pm
I understand. Some policies at some shelters are absolutely ridiculous. You're not the only one that has had bad experiences at the Brick shelter. In some areas, they excel and in others they fail...and fail miserably! I used to volunteer there until management felt like I was using the shelter to "promote my business" and that the company the shelter used to train some dogs felt threatened that I would also steal business from them. Nothing could have been farther from that!!! I was there for the animals. I had a client minutes away from the shelter and would go from my client to the shelter without changing my uniform shirt. With that said, I no longer felt comfortable there and quit volunteering.
I personally don't believe in declawing cats because that's a procedure that is actually a "toe amputation." That's why shelters have problems with that and they don't want it promoted with their animals they offer for adoption. However, spay/neutering should be a must with every dog and cat to prevent the "stray" situation from getting worse. The bottom line is this...we have many shelters in area with Ocean and Monmouth counties with different policies. The Jersey Shore Animal Shelter is not the only place we have. I recommend and encourage people interested in a cat or dog to check out all shelters and rescue organizations in the area and their policies. Some shelter even provide transportation of the pets too. The main thing is not to buy a dog from a store.
Sean Conneamhe February 15, 2012 at 02:52 am
"The property has been cited for numerous township code violations, the business has been shut down, the tenant unit has been vacated, and the signs are being removed."
Lazzari February 17, 2012 at 10:19 pm
frances I'm beginning to think most shelters are no better,,,,,I took Jersey Shore items for the puppies asked about them and offered to foster, I was met with total indifference ,told they were doing fine in the shelter and that the shelter was hoping this would be resolved quickly which I took to mean they could go up for adoption which means the shelter gets a hefty adoption fee,,,, as with babies puppies thrive in a home environment,,, basically at that point I was dismissed without even a thank you for the food & blankets ,,,,,,,
frances February 18, 2012 at 12:48 am
Lazzari, I do not have first-hand knowledge or experience with this particular shelter but it is my understanding that the Township has an ongoing relationship and contractual agreement with "Jersey Shore" so it might be a good idea for you to contact the Mayor, Council and our Business Administrator. I will reach out to them as well.
You are absolutely correct that you should not be treated with indifference. Please don't give up the good work. The animals need people like you to advocate and support their cause. And I personally APPLAUD you for your efforts. I can tell you that we adopted our dog from the Monmouth County Animal Shelter and were blessed with the best dog ever. So please don't give up on all Shelters and in the meantime continue to lend a voice to the innocent and defenseless animals. You sound like an extremely kind and compassionate human being. Again thank you for taking the time and know that your humane actions do count.
Portia February 18, 2012 at 01:14 am
Andy, it would be a travesty if JAIL TIME is not SERVED. Nat Sladkin has inflicted more harm and heartache to innocent animals, unsuspecting consumers and families for decades.
If on March 01, 2012 our Court System allows him to get away with probation, it would be an injustice beyond comprehension. JAIL TIME IS WARRANTED, and I could not agree with you more.
Jan Fisher February 29, 2012 at 10:04 pm
Does anyone know what time the hearing on the cruelty charges against DeSantis and Sladkin is tomorrow?
frances March 1, 2012 at 01:51 pm
March 15, 2012 - 4:00 pm
lisa fenimore April 20, 2012 at 10:24 pm
i worked for pet depot for 20 yrs and got numerous pets from them and they lived to be ripe old age and i never had a problem with my working there so some of you dont no them at all they love dogs and take good care of there pets and as for the one who said something about him and his wife well she has passed so please do not talk ill of her they are good people
lisa fenimore April 20, 2012 at 10:27 pm
his wife has passed so dont speak that way of her they had pet stores for over 30 yrs maybe people didnt understand not to put there hands in the cages i worked ther i should no and it was a clean store pet depot was thank you very much
Laura April 21, 2012 at 03:26 am
I guess thousands of complainants were all wrong and you are the expert.
lisa fenimore April 21, 2012 at 10:48 pm
laura yes since i worked for them and knew them outside of work but i also knew that it is people like yourselves who go into stores and put your hands in the cages and then go from one to the other spreading grems i am not saying that puppies dont get sick just like babies do but do you go in to a nursery and handle all of the babies they were in business for a long time and sold a lot of puppies that people did not have any problems with but sometime you need to look at rude people like yourselves and ask could you have did it better ...i say NOT ..thank you but there are good people and there is thousands of them that like them
Can't shut me up April 21, 2012 at 11:25 pm
@lisa fenimore
I wouldn't admit I knew these people. No less defend them....Unless your their partner in crime. Which one their many puppy mill store did you work in? Obviously they taught you well, blame the customer, vet.....Never DeSantis and Sladkin. Your laughable.
Can't shut me up April 22, 2012 at 12:04 am
Too many people I know including myself has been turned away from The Jersey Shore Animal Center. All of us were deemed "unfit". Me, because my dog was not neutered and because I used Petco for my shots. They were also abusive to me vet too. Those people shouldn't be in charge of animals. Lunitic fanatics to put it mildly. Fuzzy has been there since 10/1/11 in a 10x8 cage. 50+ applications, all of us unfit. Fuzzy still sits in this prison cell. These shelters are the reason why people go to pet store and breeders. Maybe someone should be picketing them. Their all about the profits NOT the animals. Even sadder is all the seized puppies from Puppy's Galore went there.
shoredoglover April 22, 2012 at 01:05 am
If there is any shred of truth that Jersey Shore is allowing animals to linger in the shelter indefinitely because the facility is unnecessarily rejecting qualified applicants, then perhaps the Town Council/Mayor's office should request to review the records of their application screening process. The town does pay them a fee for their services, so perhaps it is time to ask for some transparency. I am sure they do a wonderful job caring for the animals and of course, animals must be matched carefully with an adopter, however, there are quite a few of these stories surfacing so one has to wonder if they are being overly critical of would be adopters.
shoredoglover April 22, 2012 at 01:09 am
Of course, one's displeasure with how the Jersey Shore Animal Center handles its application process is still not a good reason to buy an animal from a pet store/puppy miller.
Can't shut me up April 22, 2012 at 01:42 pm
I've already spoke with the mayors office. The confirmed there have been a ton of complaints about Jersey Shore. But since they are non-profit (yea right) and not budgeted by the Brick taxpayers there is nothing they can do. Jersey Shore does get paid by Brick per job they perform.
Puppies don't grown on trees shoredoglover. AGAIN shelters like this is what prompts people to go to stores. And Fuzzy still sits in a 10 X 8 prison cell. Imprisoned since 10/1/2011.
lisa fenimore April 23, 2012 at 04:53 pm
for smartzonemary yes i worked for them and toke care of the animals and i dont no the other person but i knew sladkin very well and i didnt blame anyone for this but there is alot of customers that are not heard over the years that have gotten puppies from them at petdepot and you dont hear the good of that shelters are not always better cause you dont no waht your getting there so you can laugh all you want i know how he is and i was not in the brick store i worked for him a long time but sometime people dont listen when you tell them things ..did you no him did you get a puppy from him?

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Brick Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Mark Story Jenks June 19, 2013 at 03:27 pm
I guess not everyone appreciates the crow of a Rooster.
Lelenore Lep June 19, 2013 at 03:51 pm
I agree with quiet time. Def consideration of my neighbors if they have a sleeping baby or back yardRead More party. We surely try to respect that.
KC June 19, 2013 at 04:55 pm
Funny Lelenore, I don't see that there are very many rules and regs. If it were elected it would notRead More be an infringement. I respect your opinion, but still feel six day time hours out of an entire week is not a lot to ask. If nothing else, would love to see a ban on gas leaf blowers. There are towns that have that in place. The mowers are not really IMHO that intrusive, but the leaf blowers and concrete cutters are another matter. Trouble is, people herebouts think they are in Montana and often are as you say, on 100 by 100 lots. What is the point of having all of this grass and trees if one never has the serenity about them to enjoy it? I think the ill effects of suburban noise pollution on health - blood pressure, aggression, release of the chemical cortisol etc. are well documented. Over a twenty five year period in time in Brick I find that this has become a real quality of life issue. At one point in my life I resided in mid town Manhattan and ya know what - being high up IT WAS QUIETER! Jackson? I don't think so. Doesn't Brielle have such an elective ordinance?
GMA June 18, 2013 at 04:23 pm
It was suppose to move next to the next liquor store behind Harbor Freight on Hooper.But,they neverRead More did.And when we pass it,it looks like they aren't even working on that side of the building.We miss that place for their deli dept.
Fred y June 19, 2013 at 06:20 am
They are waiting for the new store to get dirty and smell. It needs to be run down a little bit forRead More it to function properly.
can't say who June 19, 2013 at 05:44 pm
Right next to the liquor store. The reason it is taking so long is the politics of Acropolis andRead More Pat Botazzi. They kept the liquor store from opening for TWO years by controlling the planning board and caused the store owner HUNDREDS OF THOUSANS OF DOLLARES WITH COURT FIGHTS. Acropolis LOST THE COURT FIGHTS BUT CONTINUES TO BEAT UP ON THE LIQUOR STORE'S NEW TENNANT AS RETROBUTION Now Acropolis can play the code enforcement game and still get his happiness as a bigoted soon to be ex mayor and not a nice man. How about denying this. It is going to be a great store with the same owners and great food IF Acropolis doesn't have them go bankrupt due to him before they even open.
Pictured in this lunch combo is Applebee’s new Signature Turkey Avocado Sandwich and Chicken Tortilla Soup.
KC June 18, 2013 at 04:41 pm
Looks good, but got sick as a dog from their food years back. Did I ever return? Nope.
anonymous May 1, 2013 at 08:10 pm
We're hurting 6 months after Sandy... We're frustrated... We're MAD... We need action, not talk!Read More Come to the protest rally Sat. May 4th, 2-3PM, Joey Harrison's Surf Club, 1900 Ocean Ave., Ortley Beach.
Sue May 6, 2013 at 03:54 pm
FEMA says "PAY or go away"